Everton have sparked fury amongst many fans of late, for what they see as the exploitation of a PSR loophole.
Having signed Tim Iroegbunam from Aston Villa last week, just a day later Lewis Dobbin would go in the other direction, seeing them effectively swap two academy prospects.
However, the bone of contention came in the fees: £9m and £10m respectively.
Commenters have claimed that this does not represent fair value given their lack of senior game time, and the fact that the Premier League are scrambling to close Everton’s PSR loophole suggests they have done something right.
Their peers, however, are not happy.
Premier League clubs give verdict on Everton’s PSR loophole
The latest comes courtesy of BBC Sport, who actually approached much of the Premier League to find out how they felt about Everton’s supposed misdeeds.
First seeking to gain a comment from the Toffees themselves as well as Aston Villa, Newcastle United or Chelsea, all declined to comment.
However, the rest of the division was not so prudent, as is reported: ‘But what of other Premier League clubs? We spoke to several and they seemed split.
‘One told BBC Sport that the deals were “wrong and should not be allowed”. Another said the transfers “made a mockery of the rules” and that it would be asking the Premier League for its observations.
‘Others were more relaxed, accepting that the transfers were ultimately within the rules. However, one did admit the ‘optics’ created by the transfers were unhelpful, and that the controversy only served to emphasise that PSR was too blunt an instrument, and was failing to help clubs to invest and create the best league in the world.
‘The Premier League also declined to comment. But if clubs try to circumvent its rules, they could be in breach, and it can review any transfer to check that it is being done on an arm’s length basis. If it is not, the league can assess it for ‘Fair Market Value’.’
It is also worth noting that some private sources at the first four clubs mentioned remained incensed that the prices paid reflected value fairly in the market.
Everton are no longer just happy to be there
After years of just being content with being in the Premier League, existing for the sake of existing, and barely challenging for silverware, it really feels like this summer marks a turning point.
And that’s not to suggest that the Toffees will suddenly become this club that consistently fights atop the league table, but no longer are they going to sit and be the whipping boy of the division.
Last season was the real tipping point, as two points deductions left them feeling alienated throughout.
The fans were incensed, and rightly so, whilst the club itself valiantly fought its position.
Now, many months on, this PSR loophole is the perfect retort from a club that has been beaten, bruised and pushed down.
Well, they are now rising up, and whilst it will not be instant, there is scope for excitement at Everton once again. After all, if their squeaky-clean reputation must be the price they pay, then so be it. It was about time Evertonians had a little fun whilst watching football again.
Receive a digest of our best Everton content each week direct to your mailbox
