Goodison Park was no stranger to a chorus of boos from Everton fans, and groans could be heard on this day back in 2016 after a bizarre match under Roberto Martinez.
It was the first time Salomon Rondon played at Goodison Park, starting for West Brom before eventually moving to Everton in August 2021.
Before becoming a Toffee himself, the Venezuelan scored a goal to ensure Everton went down in Premier League history for unprecedented levels of inefficiency.
Who do you have down as Everton’s greatest-ever manager? 👏
Let us know who and why! 🤩
When Everton failed to score despite taking 34 shots at West Brom
On February 13th 2016, Tony Pulis took his West Brom side to Goodison Park, where Martinez – who wanted more time on Merseyside – watched his Everton team absolutely dominate the Baggies.
- Shots: Everton 34 – 1 West Brom
- Possession: Everton 76% – 24% West Brom
- Corners: Everton 14 – 1 West Brom
- Woodwork: Everton hit the post twice (Ross Barkley and Tom Cleverley)
Despite recording 34 shots and 76% of the possession, Everton failed to break West Brom down, and ultimately went on to suffer a 1-0 defeat after Rondon bundled in a loose ball at the back post in scruffy style.
It was West Brom’s only shot on target.
Everton set a Premier League record that day for the most shots taken by a losing side, and actually still hold that position right now despite a valiant effort from Tottenham in December 2023 against West Ham.
| Team | Opponent | Date | Shots | Final Score |
| Everton | West Brom | February 13 2016 | 34 | L 0–1 |
| Chelsea | Birmingham City | November 20 2010 | 32 | L 0–1 |
| Tottenham | West Ham | December 7 2023 | 23 | L 1–2 |
It’s better than recording zero shots on target and going on to lose, we suppose, but this arguably remains one of the most embarrassing results in Premier League history.
Salomon Rondon almost matched his Goodison Park goal record for Everton in this match
To make matters worse for Everton, the hero on this day in Rondon – who stunned fans in 2024 – never managed to find hero status on Merseyside when playing for the Toffees.
In total, the 36-year-old only scored two goals in 14 appearances for Everton at Goodison Park, just one more than he managed for West Brom in one match at the same venue.
Which former Everton striker would you hypothetically bring back to play in the current side? 🤩
Everton, that.
Receive a digest of our best Everton content each week direct to your mailbox
