It is time to vote for your Everton 2025/26 Player of the Season.
Everton remain in the hunt for European qualification following what has been a much-improved campaign for the Toffees.
Here are our 10 nominees for the Everton News Player of the Season award, where you can cast your vote via the poll at the bottom of the article.
Jordan Pickford
Jordan Pickford has been another key component of Everton’s relevant success this season in between the sticks.
With three games remaining, only two other goalkeepers – David Raya (17) and Gianluigi Donnarumma (13) – have kept more clean sheets than Pickford (11).
James Tarkowski
James Tarkowski has played 90 minutes in all bar one of Everton’s Premier League games this season.
A constant feature in David Moyes’ starting XI and led the side as on-field captain amid Seamus Coleman’s absence.
Clearly a Moyes favourite.
Michael Keane
Having signed a new contract over the summer, Michael Keane has earned himself another one-year extension to keep him around for next season.
The defender has been a serious goal threat for the Blues having found the back of the net three times in the Premier League.
James Garner
Thomas Tuchel handed James Garner his England debut just a matter of weeks ago following a fine showing this season for the Blues.
Garner has started every game for Everton in the league this season and played just about every minute, with Moyes utilising his versatility.
Idrissa Gana Gueye
Although Idrissa Gana Gueye missed some weeks through the Africa Cup of Nations, the Senegal international instantly returned to Moyes’ side.
Everton are still discussing a new deal for Gueye, with the 36-year-old on course to become a free agent this summer.
Iliman Ndiaye
Another of Everton’s Senegal representatives, Iliman Ndiaye has enjoyed another productive campaign under Moyes.
Even Thierry Henry praised Ndiaye following Everton’s draw against Manchester City. The winger has netted six goals and provided three assists.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
What an addition Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall has proven to be for Everton. The midfielder has scored eight times and provided six Premier League assists.
A number of Everton supporters want Dewsbury-Hall to become the next captain – that is how good he has been.
Jack Grealish
Although Jack Grealish has been absent for months due to his significant injury blow, he, like Dewsbury-Hall, was another fantastic summer addition.
Everton are in talks to sign Grealish in the coming window, with the Blues hopeful of landing his services either on loan again or in a permanent deal.
Beto
Beto has picked up some form over recent weeks, with the 28-year-old striker having scored eight times in the Premier League – seven of those coming in 2026.
During January, Everton received interest in Beto from clubs on the continent, but it proved a good decision to keep him on Merseyside.
Thierno Barry
A controversial one, but it is impossible not to include Everton’s joint-top scorer, Thierno Barry.
Everton supporters have booed Barry this season following an incident after the loss away to Arsenal.
He has a lot to prove after a turbulent campaign.
- Now it is time to cast your vote…
VOTE NOW for your Everton 2025/26 Player of the Season 🗳️
There are some great players to choose from! 🔥
Receive a digest of our best Everton content each week direct to your mailbox
